The 2025-26 College Football Playoff is finally here, and this year’s field offers one of the most compelling mixes of dominant defenses, high-octane offenses, and quarterback storylines we’ve seen in a decade. With four programs entering the postseason convinced they can win the national title, bettors face a rare playoff where every matchup hinges on contrasting identities and razor-thin margins. Here’s a breakdown of the teams, the semifinal matchups, and the betting angles that could decide the 2025 CFP.
The top four seeds – who receive first-round byes – are: Indiana (No. 1), Ohio State (No. 2), Georgia (No. 3), and Texas Tech (No. 4). The rest of the field – seeds 5 through 12 – will kick things off the week of December 19-20 in first-round games at campus sites. Tulane enters as the No. 11 seed. They’ll travel to face No. 6 seed Mississippi in the first round. James Madison is the No. 12 seed and opens on the road against No. 5 seed Oregon.
🔥 Spotlight Teams: Indiana, Ohio State, JMU & Tulane
Indiana – No. 1 Seed, Big Ten Champion
Indiana stunned the college football world by knocking off Ohio State in the Big Ten title game and finishing 13–0. That impressive run earned the Hoosiers the top seed in the CFP. This is uncharted territory for the program: first time as No. 1, and only their second playoff berth overall.
Betting angle: As the top seed with a bye, Indiana represents a strong “safe” futures play. They avoid the volatility and injuries of a first-round game, and if their momentum is real, they could be the team to bet on for a deep run, especially if they draw a manageable quarterfinal opponent (likely the winner of No. 8 vs. No. 9).
Ohio State – No. 2 Seed, Title-Chaser
Despite losing the Big Ten title game to Indiana, Ohio State still landed the No. 2 seed and a first-round bye. The Buckeyes remain one of the most battle-tested, elite-rostered squads in college football – with the talent and experience to make another deep run.
Betting angle: Ohio State remains the “safe upside” pick: a strong roster, a bye, and fewer variables. Given their path avoids Indiana until possibly later rounds, they’ll be a popular pick in futures markets. Indeed, many oddsmakers list OSU among the top favorites to win it all.
Tulane – No. 11 Seed & Dark-Horse Value
Tulane, the American Conference champion, snagged the No. 11 seed and a first-round road trip to Ole Miss. Their inclusion – alongside another non-Power 5 team – shows that the expanded playoff now gives real shots to programs outside the traditional power leagues.
Betting angle: Tulane is the kind of “Poison Pill + high-reward” underdog bet that could pay off big. If they can pull off an upset at Ole Miss, the bracket suddenly swings wide open. For bettors, Tulane overs, upset props, or even a dark-horse futures bet could offer high value.
James Madison – No. 12 Seed & Long-Shot Cinderella
James Madison, representing the Sun Belt Conference, grabbed the No. 12 seed and a tough trip to Oregon in the first round. That said, the Dukes’ presence in the field at all – as a Group of Five champion – highlights how the new 12-team format changes the dynamics.
Betting angle: As the lowest seed, JMU is obviously a big underdog — but that means high payout potential. Betting markets may undervalue them, especially if bettors are hung up on “power conference” bias. A JMU upset at Oregon would be one of the biggest stories of the playoffs.
✅ Betting Outlook: What We’re Watching & Recommended Moves
-
Expect sharp movement in futures markets early, as soon as first-round winners are determined, odds will shift significantly.
-
For conservative bettors: Indiana or Ohio State futures + a couple of “safe overs” or line plays.
-
For bold bettors / bracket pools: Tulane moneyline or JMU moneyline, possibly a small futures stake on them to win it all — the payoff could be massive if they catch fire.
-
Look for props tied to first-round games: total points, margin of victory, upset specials — especially with weather and home-field factors now in play.
-
As the field narrows, re-evaluate matchups: injuries, momentum, and fatigue will matter. Don’t get locked into early favorites.
Oskeim Sports gives free College Football Picks, College Football Predictions, NFL Picks, NFL Predictions, NBA Picks, NBA Predictions, MLB Picks, MLB Predictions, NHL Picks, and NHL Predictions throughout the 2025-26 seasons. Oskeim Sports has been an industry-leading sports handicapping service since 2007. Its lead handicapper, Jeff Keim, has received 73 awards in football, basketball, baseball, and hockey, including 15 handicapping championships and 53 Top 5 finishes. Visit daily for free NBA and college basketball odds, totals, and free picks. Oskeim gives the best daily free picks in the sports handicapping industry.
Join Oskeim Sports today and save 20% on your first purchase at the online store!